Sarah's - The First Ingredient is Love

  • facebook twitter
  • Great food. Flawless
    presentation. Smooth service.

    Sarah's Catering

    Have a Special Event coming up? Sarah's Caters is here for You! Send us an Email to get started. Any event is Possible!

  • Recent Comments

    • "Thank you for a very successful Rehearsal Dinner at Reid St. Park last Week! Our guests were thrilled with the event, the food, the service and even the foggy, cool ambiance. Your decisions with the hot soup, the soft shell and hard shell lobster were perfect, and your input and patience were invaluable to me. We are so very happy with the outcome! Looking forward to visiting Sarah's many times in the years to come.
      Best wishes, Fan Tuttle"

      "Our Favorite Place!! We moved here [to Maine] because of Sarah's!! :)" Denise & Carlo Gallello, Westport Island, ME."

      I absolutely LOVE coming to Sarah's! The food is incredible and the staff is simply wonderful! I am always trying something different every time I come because I know whatever I order, it is going to be GOOD! The homemade breads for the soup are always a great starter and the whale boats are amazing! Look forward to coming back soon!!
      I would like to thank you and your staff for helping me to stay on a gluten free diet while vacationing in your area. We have been coming to Wiscasset area for many years, usually in October and we love eating at your place. Your cafe always feels warm and inviting and your food outstanding. Thanks, Lonnie and Barbara from Missouri

      My husband and I stopped in last year for lunch and it was the best decision we could have made. The food and service was incredible. Unfortunately we live in Needham, Mass. and cannot get there often.
      I was mainly blown away with your Blueberry Martini and was wondering if you could give me the recipe. PLEASE!!
      Hope to see you all soon! Linda (Needham, MA)

      Your staff was amazing and the food sublime!!! We are still enjoying the leftovers but wishing a few more of those scrumptious crab cakes had remained. The that was without question the BEST ever tasted....we are all shoveling the remaining in and not regretting one fat gram. Absolutely wonderful...blueberry spice has our vote! Meg & Carl, Westport Isle. ME

      Dear Sarah:
      We made a wonderful choice for caterers. Everyone at our reception thought the food, decorations, staff, etc. were excellent.
      Of course we had one of the most beautiful days yet this summer. Thank you for a job well done.
      Debbie and Don Snyder, Boothbay Harbor

      "Dear Sarah & Matthew,
      I want to express my appreciation to you & your staff for the FIVE STAR service delivered both at Mary's Remembrance party & the follow up supper at our house.." Sincerely, J. Leanord; Georgetown, ME

      "We visit Maine every fall, started in 1989 and have ALWAYS gone to Sarah's for at least one meal. Most times more than once. Best desserts, soups and breads on the east side of the Rockies." ~ Lititz Pa

      "Sarah, You Have the Best Lobster Roll! Even better than we've got in Portland." Tom from Portland


      "Special St. Patty's Day Salad. DELICIOUS!" -Sandy Hopkins & Family

    • April 2018
      S M T W T F S
      « Jun    

    Route 1 Wiscasset Village (207) 882 7504 Open Daily 11am - 8pm

    Sarah, her Sons Clayton & Matthew & Long Time Head Chef, Sandy have created this Mouth Watering, Fresh, Homemade, Made from the best & bare essentials, sinful & expansive Menu over the past 36 Years!  Take a Look & Give us a Shout!


       “For Starters”

    Loaded Nachos crispy nacho chips with cheddar and mozzarella cheeses , onions, peppers, tomato &   black olives. Served with sides of sour cream,   Sarah’s salsa and guacamole   $12.50 add burger   or chicken $1.50 (smaller size Loaded Nachos $9.50)

    Hot Nachos crisp nacho chips w/ cheddar and mozzarella  cheeses served w/ sour cream & Sarah’s salsa   $10 (smaller size Nachos $8)

    Toasted Nacho Chips served w/ Sarah’s salsa $5.30 or w/ Sarah’s guacamole $5.50

    Garlic Bread fresh baked bread topped with garlic but-  ter, cheddar & mozzarella served hot w/ side of   sauce $6.50

    Baked Potato Skins w/ bacon and cheddar. Served   with side of sour cream $6.95

    Quesadilla a 12” flour tortilla stuffed with loads of cheddar, baked till golden brown & served   with Sarah’s salsa & sour cream $9  (addl. meat $1.50; veggie .50)

    Oven Fries and Gravy oven fries served with a side   of beef gravy $6

    Sarah’s Crab Cakes two homemade crab cakes grilled   and served on a bed of crispy greens w/ sides of   homemade tartar sauce & lemon   $12

    Sarah’s Famous “Whaleboat”

    Our version of a calzone, your choice of white or wheat,

    with mozzarella and cheddar, baked till golden brown.

    Served w/ pizza sauce on request .75

    The Captains Cut, steak, sautéed onion, bacon, mushrooms,   tomatoes, cheddar & mozzarella $11.50

    Greek, spinach, tomato, red onion, Greek olives, feta, pepperoncini, mozzarella & vinaigrette $11

    Crows Nest, spinach, tomato, red onion, sprouts, mush  rooms, cheddar, mozzarella & vinaigrette $10

    The Bunk, your choice of Pepperoni or Ham with cheddar &   mozzarella $9.50

    Sunken Treasure spinach, tomato, mushrooms, broccoli,   pesto, mozzarella & cheddar $10.50

    Harbor Master corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, mozzarella   & spicy brown mustard $10

    Helmsman Your choice of Turkey or Bacon with tomato,   spinach, mozzarella & cheddar $10

    The Deck Hand hamburger, sautéed onions, tomatoes,

    bacon, cheddar & mozzarella $11

    The Lobster Trap Maine Lobster meat, spinach, tomato,   cheddar & mozzarella (market)

    Haddock Boat lemon butter baked haddock, spinach, tomato,   mozzarella and cheddar $17

    Build Your Own Boat includes: 1 meat & 2 veggies, cheddar and mozzarella $8.75

    Please see additional toppings and prices opposite page

    The Matey

    A dough blanket wrapped around your choice of filling including cheddar and mozzarella and baked till golden brown

    You can have a smaller version of any above whaleboat for $1 less

    Or build your own Mateys!!

     The following items have been a favorite at Sarah’s for over 36 years!

    The Cabin Girl (Sarah’s original classic), spinach, tomato, red onion, mushrooms, sprouts, sour cream, mozzarella & cheddar cheese wrapped in a dough blanket & baked till golden brown $8.75

    The Yard Arm (Sarah’s original classic) w/ a natural casing frank, bacon, cheddar & mozzarella wrapped in a dough blanket & baked till golden brown $8.75

    Steak Matey:  Grilled Shaved Steak, Bacon, Cheddar & Mozzarella.  $9

    B.B.Q. Roast Beef Matey:  Sliced Roast Beef, Barbecue Sauce, Cheddar & Mozzarella.  $9

    Sarah’s Famous Fresh Dough Pizza

    Topped w/ our pizza, barbecue or garlic sauce, a blend of cheeses and your choice of toppings on a white, wheat or (10”gluten free crust $2)

               9”             12”                 15”

    Cheese       $8.25           $10.25                 $13.25

    Basic Toppings     $1.25          $1.75       $2.25

    Premium Toppings    $1.75      $3.25          $4.25

    Addl. Cheese    $2             $3.50           $4.50

      Gluten Free Crust   (9” only) $2.00

    Basic Toppings: red onions, black olives, tomatoes, peppers,

    mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, pineapple, jalapenos, garlic, sprouts

    Premium Toppings: Greek olives, corned beef, steak, hamburger, chicken, sausage, pepperoni, hot dog, feta cheese, anchovies, ricotta cheese, pesto, Swiss cheese, artichokes, pepperoncini, goat cheese

    Maine Lobster Meat ask for market pricing.

            Specialty Pizzas

    Meat Loaded w/ pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese, topped w/   sausage, ham, pepperoni & hamburger $12   $16   $20

    Veggie Loaded w/ pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese, topped w/   spinach, tomato, red onion, peppers, mushrooms, black olives   $10.50   $14.50   $18.50

    Greek w/ pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese, topped w/ spinach,   tomato, red onion, peppers, Greek olives, pepperoncini &   Feta $11.50  $15.50   $19.50

    Hawaiian w/ pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese, topped w/ ham   and fresh pineapple     $10.50   $14   $18

    Mashed Potato & Bacon sour cream, garlic sauce, mashed   potato, cheddar, mozzarella, bacon & chives  $11   $15   $19

    Philly Steak w/ garlic sauce topped with mozzarella, sliced     prime beef, sautéed onions, peppers $11    $15   $19

    Windjammer Gourmet (Sarah’s famous lobster pizza) w/   garlic sauce, mozzarella, topped w/ lobster meat, tomatoes, scallions & lemons (market)

    Sarah’s Maine lobster entrées (market price)

    Fresh rolls and buns baked daily, ask for our choices!                                              (gluten free for additional price)

    The Lobster Roll (white or wheat of the day) our famous   grilled roll stuffed w/ Maine lobster meat gently tossed   with fine diced celery, mayo, salt and pepper and a bit of   lettuce served with chips and pickle.                                                                                                                        (Plain lobster meat and drawn butter $2.50 additional)

    Fresh Mixed Garden or Spinach salad topped w/ lobster   salad served with garlic bread

    Lobster Wrap or Quesadilla a 12” flour tortilla filled w/   fresh lobster meat, spinach, tomato & cheddar,   baked till golden brown & served w/ Sarah’s salsa,   sour cream, guacamole (market)

    Lobster Grilled Cheese on sliced bread with tomatoes,  Maine lobster meat and Swiss cheese w/ sides of   chips & pickle

    Lobster Salad Club lettuce, tomato, bacon, cheddar and lobster salad on your choice of a grilled bun or   sliced bread w/ sides of chips & pickle

    Lobster Trap Maine lobster meat, spinach, tomato, cheddar   & mozzarella cooked calzone style (market)

    Windjammer Gourmet (Sarah’s famous lobster pizza) w/   garlic sauce, mozzarella & topped w/ lobster meat,   tomatoes, scallions & lemons (market)

    Sarah’s Roll Ups

    12” white or wheat tortilla served w/ chips and pickle

    Chicken Caesar   romaine lettuce, roasted chicken, shredded parmesan, cheddar cheese, Caesar dressing $9.50

    Roasted Lemon Pepper Chicken Salad tomatoes, lettuce &   cheddar cheese $8.75   (add bacon for $1.50)

    B.L.T. w/ cheddar $9

    Veggie w/ spinach, tomato, peppers, red onion, sprouts,   mushrooms & cheddar $9.50

    Choice of Ham or Roast Turkey Deluxe w/ bacon, tomatoes, red onion, lettuce & cheddar   $9.50

    Steak Loaded thinly sliced prime steak with grilled onions,   peppers, mushrooms and cheddar $10

     Sarah’s Fresh Catch

    Sarah’s Crab Cakes:  Two of Sarah’s Famous Grilled Maine Crab Cakes, served on a bed of Greens & Veggies.  With a choice of 2 Sides & Tartar Sauce.   $15

    Haddock Melt baked in a lemon parsley butter on a bulky  bun served hot w/ cheddar w/ sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, lemon, chips and pickle $14.50

    Haddock Matey baked in a lemon parsley butter,   wrapped w/ mozzarella & cheddar, spinach & tomato   in a fresh dough blanket. Baked till golden brown &   served w/ homemade tartar sauce, lemon   $14.50

    Baked Haddock filet on sliced tomatoes, topped w/ Swiss and baked casserole style. Served w/ a   mixed green salad, tartar sauce & lemon   $16.50

    Haddock Wrap a 12” flour tortilla wrapped around fresh lemon baked haddock, spinach, tomato & cheddar   cheese. Baked till golden brown & served w/ Sarah’s   salsa, sour cream, guacamole & lemon $18.50

    Crab Cake Burger two grilled crab cakes topped w/ Swiss   cheese on a grilled bun w/ sides of lettuce, tomato,   homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle & lemon $15.50

    Haddock Crab Deluxe fresh haddock baked in a lemon butter, topped w/ a grilled crab cake & cheddar   cheese on a grilled bun .Served w/ sides of lettuce,   tomato, homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle &   lemon $17.50

    Parmesan Haddock fresh haddock oven fried in a parmesan   breading on your choice of bun. Served w/ sides of  lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle & lemon $15.50

    Haddock Club fresh haddock baked in a lemon butter topped with bacon , Swiss, lettuce and tomato  on a grilled bun with sides of homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle and lemon $17

    Pesto Haddock fresh haddock baked in a lemon butter topped with pesto sauce and Swiss cheese on a   grilled bun with sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade   tartar sauce, chips, pickle and lemon $16

    Sarah’s Haddock Shepard’s Pie:  Fresh Haddock Filet, baked in Sarah’s Cream Sauce, with Peas & Mashed Potatoes. Served with Cole Slaw.   $17


    potato salad, coleslaw $3 mashed potatoes and gravy, oven fries, macaroni and cheese , demi salad homemade applesauce or butternut squash $4                         Cup of Soup $4

    Sarah’s 8 oz. Sirloin Burgers

    6 oz. sirloin burger. Served with lettuce, tomato, pickle and chips $9.75

    Turkey or Veggie burgers available

             Ask about today’s choice of fresh baked buns                                                         (gluten free buns additional charge: $2)

    (You may choose the following at additional prices)

    Swiss, blue cheese, cheddar, bacon, feta, pesto, American cheese, guacamole or goat cheese $1.50 ea.

    grilled onions, mushrooms, red onions, pineapple jalapeños, peppers or tomato .50 ea.

    All Breads Baked Fresh Daily

    Sarah’s Fresh Oven Baked Sandwiches

    Served with chips and pickle

    On your choice of Bun, French bread or Sliced bread

    **gluten free $2**

    **served grilled unless specified**

     Roasted Lemon Pepper Chicken Salad w/ lettuce & tomato   $8.75

    Steak, thinly sliced steak, mushrooms, sautéed onions, mozza-  rella & cheddar cheese $10

    Reuben, slow cooked corned beef, thinly sliced, sauerkraut,   thousand island, mozzarella and Swiss $9.50

    Ham, cheddar & mozzarella cheese $9

    1/2 sandwich w/ cup of soup sliced bread or French bread only   $8.75                                              (seafood omitted)

     Turkey, peppers, tomatoes, sautéed onion, bacon, lettuce,

    mozzarella & cheddar cheese $9.75

    Grilled American cheese w/ tomatoes (on sliced bread only)   $8

    BLT (no cheese) can substitute spinach instead of lettuce $9

    Greek w/ spinach, red onion, peppers, tomatoes, Greek olives,

    pepperoncini, mozzarella and Feta $9.50

    Veggie, spinach, tomatoes, red onion, mushrooms, peppers,   sprouts mozzarella & cheddar cheese $9.50

    Steak Loaded Steak Sub thinly sliced steak w/ grilled onions,   peppers, mushrooms & Swiss $10

    goat cheese or feta cheese can be added for $1.50


    Sarah’s Salads

    Sarah’s is a very proud member of the Maine Organic Gardeners Association

    Enjoy a cup of chowder or soup with your salad $4

    The Chef  An assortment of mixed greens and seasonal vegetables topped w/ sliced cheddar and Swiss,   choice of one; ham, pepperoni, chicken, turkey   or anchovies, a boiled egg, and served w/ garlic   bread   sm.  $8  lg.  $10

    Beef & Blue Salad Grilled sliced prime beef topped on   a mixed green salad w/ seasonal vegetables,   crumbled blue cheese, bacon & garlic bread.   sm.  $9.75  lg.  $12.75

    Garden crisp lettuce w/ seasonal vegetables & sprouts,   served w/ garlic bread                         sm.  $4.70  lg.  $6.70

    Spinach w/ crisp seasonal vegetables & sprouts, served   w/ garlic bread                                   sm.  $4.70  lg.  $6.70

    Sarah’s Cobb Salad   w/ assorted mixed greens and seasonal vegetables topped w/ sliced turkey, bacon, boiled egg & crumbled blue cheese.  Served w/ garlic bread                                  sm $9.50  lg  $12.50

    Boothbay Harbor Crab Cobb Salad mixed greens &   crisp seasonal veggies topped w/ blue cheese   crumbles garnished w/ two grilled crab cakes,   crisp bacon, boiled egg, garlic bread & lemon   slice $16.                                                                                                              Enjoy a smaller version w/ One Crab Cake for:  $12

    Taco Salad a crispy nacho chip framed salad with   lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, peppers, red on  ions &   cheddar with your choice of hamburger,   chicken, steak or turkey. Topped with sour   cream, salsa and guacamole.   sm.  $9.50  lg.  $11.50

    Greek spinach, red onions, peppers, cucumbers, Greek  olives, tomatoes, feta cheese & pepperoncini,   served   w/ garlic bread sm.  $8.50  lg. $9.75

    Caesar Salad romaine lettuce tossed with our home  made Caesar dressing, carrots, cabbage, crou-  tons & shredded parmesan cheese. sm.  $6.50  lg.  $8.50

    Sarah’s Seasonal Salad tender greens, seasonal berries,   toasted walnuts, goat cheese crumbles  sm.  $8.50   lg  $10.50

    Choice of our homemade dressings;

    house vinaigrette, fat free raspberry vinaigrette, ranch, blue cheese, parmesan pepper, thousand island

    (Goat cheese or feta cheese available $1)



    Pepsi* Diet Pepsi* Sierra Mist* Mug* Mountain Dew* Ginger Ale   $2.20

    Sarah-nade $4 (pomegranate & homemade lemonade)

    Blueberry Lemonade $4

    Bottled Water $1.95

    Carbonated Poland Spring Water $1.95

    Capt. Eli’s Root Beer, Blueberry Soda, Ginger Beer   $2.95

    Milk Med. $2 Lg. $2.75

    Chocolate Milk Med. $2.50 Lg. $3

    Orange, cranberry, apple, blueberry Juice  Med. $2 Lg. $3

     Sarah’s Homemade Lemonade (seasonal) Sm. $2 Med. $3 Lg. $4

    Hot Chocolate with real whipped cream $2.25

    Fresh Coffee Columbian or Decaffeinated $1.75

    Iced Coffee $2

    Tea (regular or decaf) $1.75

    (Assorted herbal tea available)

    Sarah’s Fresh Brewed Iced Tea $2.20 

    Be sure to check out our fresh baked daily sinful cakes, pies, cookies, éclairs and so much more!

    Over 35 Years, Sarah’s Catering has earned an

    outstanding reputation as one of Maine’s premier

    caterers and event planners. From corporate and business celebrations, conferences and meetings to grand ocean front weddings and any event in



     Pizza Paddle jpeg


























      © 2018 Sarah's Café. All Rights Reserved.